Tudor Black Bay 58 Owner Review : Timeless, completed and beautiful

5.0

7

93

Published on 1/4/2026 - Last modified on 1/4/2026

Perfect

A revival of the 1958 model, this Black Bay 58 has truly made a successful comeback. Having owned several brand-name watches, I must say that this BB 58 ticks all the boxes. Its aluminum bezel, its 39mm case, its perfectly sized crown, its gold-plated hour markers and hands, its very comfortable bracelet, and its simultaneously vintage and modern look are all highlights. I would add that the clasp is of a quality I haven't encountered anywhere else, to my knowledge, and the winding mechanism is exceptionally smooth. The bezel also has incredible clicks. Finally, I'll mention that it's a no-date watch; I prefer this complication, except when the date is displayed at 6 o'clock. Tudor, Rolex's little sister, makes one wonder if the latter is of higher quality? I have only one word to describe this BB 58: Perfect

Black Duck own this watch for 3 to 10 years

5

5.0

Emotion

5.0

Design

5.0

Accuracy

5.0

Comfort

5.0

Robustness

5.0

Value for money

Secondary

Significance in a collection

Main

Rarely

Frequency to be worn

Often

Pleasure

Main motivation for buying

Investment

Pros & Cons for this watch

Its manufacturing quality; No date;

This review is the subjective opinion of a Dialicious community member and not of Achille SAS or its teams

Where to buy your Tudor?

We don't have any partners to offer you yet.

The order of partners is random and does not assume available stocks or sales prices of watches. Dialicious and Achille SAS are in no way responsible for the services of these partners but may potentially be paid by them to be displayed on this page.

img.randomAdvertisingImg

Other reviews published by Black Duck

Other Tudor Black Bay 58 owners' reviews

Customize your Tudor with our selection of accessories:

The order of partners is random. Dialicious and Achille SAS are in no way responsible for the services of these partners, but may potentially be paid by them to be featured on this page.

You own a Tudor Black Bay 58 ?

Take the opportunity to share why and how you love it

© Dialicious 2019 - 2026